While we have a lot of primary materials for North Carolina, we'll have to do some digging to find references to your church and it's history. You may already be familiar with the following and if not, it may be a good place to start:
Grissom, W. L. (William Lee), 1857-1912.
History of Methodism in North Carolina, from 1772 to the present time.
Stacks | BX8248.N8 G8 1905
If you have names of former pastors, we can sometimes find obituary information and sometimes journals/memoirs. If you have key dates for buildings or other changes to the congregation, we may find information in old conference journals and newspapers.